The Orphans of Eritrea: Are Orphanages Part of the Problem or Part of the Solution?

Abstract


Objective: This study compared the mental health and cognitive development of 9- to 12-year-old Eritrean war orphans living in two orphanages that differed qualitatively in patterns of staff interaction and styles of child care management. Method: The directors and several child care workers at each institution were asked to complete staff organization and child management questionnaires. The psychological state of 40 orphans at each institution was evaluated by comparing their behavioral symptoms and performance on cognitive measures. Results: Orphans who lived in a setting where the entire staff participated in decisions affecting the children, and where the children were encouraged to become self-reliant through personal interactions with staff members, showed significantly fewer behavioral symptoms of emotional distress than orphans who lived in a setting where the director made decisions, daily routines were determined by explicit rules and schedules, and interactions between staff members and the children were impersonal. Conclusions: When orphanages are the only means of survival for war orphans, a group setting where the staff shares in the responsibilities of child management, is sensitive to the individuality of the children, and establishes stable personal ties with the children serves the emotional needs and psychological development of the orphans more effectively than a group setting that attempts to create a secure environment through an authoritative style of management with explicit rules and well-defined schedules.



Peter H. Wolff Gebremeskel Fesseha | source: The American Journal of Psychiatry 147 |
Categories: Psychology Sociology Care


Other articles

Care arrangement, grief, and psychological problems among children orphaned by AIDS in China

The China Ministry of Health has estimated that there are at least 100,000 AIDS orphans in China. The UNICEF China Office…

Read more

Parental death in childhood and self-inflicted injuries in young adults-a national cohort study from Sweden

Previous studies have shown that parental death influences health and mortality in bereaved offspring. To date, few studies…

Read more

“Orphans” or Veterans? Justice for Children Born of War in East Timor

All over East Timor, one can find “orphans” whose parents still live, and “wives” who have never been married. These labels…

Read more

Qualitative research report on orphans and vulnerable children in Palapye, Botswana

In 2002, the Human Sciences Research Council was commissioned by the WK Kellogg Foundation to develop and implement a five-year…

Read more